Blog
  
SAVE AND SHARE RSS

A (Popular) ETF Down 97%???
Written by Matt Hougan  -  June 04, 2009 18:31 PM
Related ETFs: FAS / FAZ

I spent part of this morning sorting through the May fund flow numbers to see if any new patterns showed up in terms of where investors were putting their new money to work.

You can access the full report here. The data is from the National Stock Exchange.

There’s a lot of interesting information in the latest report, including a complete table showing assets and inflows by ETF provider. Of all the data points covered, however, one in particular caught my eye.

So far this year, the Direxion Financial Bear 3x ETF (NYSE: FAZ) has attracted the second-greatest inflow of any ETF on the market, at $4.6 billion. Only the SPDR Equity Gold (NYSE: GLD) has done better, pulling in $11.8 billion.

Despite the massive inflows, FAZ ended May with just $1.6 billion in assets. Such a gap suggests that investors in the fund have experienced terrible returns.

And they have. Since FAZ launched in November 2008, the security has lost 93% of its value, falling from $71.41 per share last November 6 all the way down to $4.83 per share on Wednesday.

The numbers look more extreme if you measure from the ETF’s peak-to-trough. Using end-of-day closing prices, FAZ rallied in the 10 days after its launch from $71.41 to $165.48 per share. The fund peaked intraday above $200 per share, according to Yahoo Finance. Using those measures, the fund is off either 97% or 98% from its high point.

Such a view makes the success of the fund in attracting assets all that more intriguing. Investors keep pouring money into the fund despite the massive losses.

Or, perhaps I should say, traders are flocking to FAZ. Despite having just $1.6 billion in assets at the end of May, $43 billion worth of FAZ shares traded hands in May. That’s $2.2 billion per day, meaning the fund turned over its entire portfolio every single trading day of the month.

What to draw from all this? The suggestion is that people are using this fund correctly, as a trading tool and not as a long-term investment. Let’s hope so. With the fund down 97%, a longer-term investment strategy just doesn’t seem to be working out.

As a trading tool, the fund is delivering on its promises, providing 3X the inverse daily return of the Russell 1000 Financial Index. But you wouldn’t want to own it for the long haul.

BTW: In case you’re wondering, FAZ’s mirror fund—the Direxion Financial Bull 3x ETF (NYSE: FAS)—is trading down 80% over the same time period.

If you’re wondering how a 3X bull and 3X bear ETF can both be down sharply over the same stretch, I encourage you to watch our recent webinar on how leveraged and short ETFs work.

 

 

Latest comments on this feature


Post a Comment

Comment
(Limit 2,000
characters) 
*
Name: *
E-mail: *
Home page:

(optional)

Type in the displayed characters:
Email follow-up comments to my e-mail address
 
 
Be up-to-date


 

Related Features