|
Page 1 of 2
With the recently completed merger between two giant exchanges, large-scale migrations are starting to take place among exchange-traded funds.
And the pace is likely to pick up as the New York Stock Exchange Euronext phases out the American Stock Exchange's ETF platform. Support for stock and ETF trading at the AMEX is scheduled to conclude on Dec. 1, according to NYSE officials.
Last week, State Street Global Advisors undertook the biggest single-day transfer of ETFs ever seen, moving 76 funds from the AMEX to the NYSE on Nov. 7. And on Oct. 31, Invesco PowerShares Capital Management moved 74 ETFs between the exchanges.
Most other major ETF providers have already started or neared completing shifting funds from the AMEX, which used to be the biggest ETF trading platform in the world. Now that's changing as it merges with NYSE, a gigantic integration process unlike the industry has ever seen for ETFs.
While such a massive move is unprecedented in size for the ETF world, some definite pluses could result, point out industry observers.
One of the major pluses could be to help spur the development of globally cross-listed ETFs for the fund industry's fastest-growing product line. That's particularly of concern since the AMEX did not have the global reach of NYSE Euronext.
At the same time, fund companies are making more connections with overseas exchanges. This pursuit of so-called cross-listings in a number of different exchanges for the same ETFs is picking up steam across markets in Europe, Asia, the Middle East and Latin America.
In fact, in the future, such cross-listing strategies are expected to become even more key to the continued growth and scope of U.S.-based ETF providers.
"One of the biggest potentials to explore as a result of our relationship with NASDAQ and our move to NYSE is cross-border listings of ETFs," said Benjamin Fulton, executive vice president of global product development for Invesco PowerShares Capital Management.
Industry data supports the increased focus on global cross-listings of ETFs.
Europe Eclipses U.S. ETF Growth Rate
The U.S. is the most mature of all ETF markets. As a result, some analysts expect its growth rate to slow in comparison to less-saturated ETF markets overseas. Recent asset growth in Europe, in particular (where ETFs are still new to many retail markets) has eclipsed the growth rate in the U.S.
Through the end of the third quarter, ETF assets in Europe were up 13% in 2008. At the same time, U.S. ETF assets fell 6.6%, according to data compiled by Barclays Global Investors' global ETF research and implementation strategy team.
PowerShares' Fulton notes that both the NYSE and NASDAQ are increasing efforts to develop more-comprehensive guidelines for cross-listings. "The global consolidation of the exchanges is the driver, and the gaps are being bridged," he said.
SSgA's senior managing director Jim Ross agrees. "There's definitely a lot more discussion about it now than when I first started looking at it. And what we're seeing in terms of global flows into ETFs lends itself to global cross-listings, which should emerge as a trend within 2009," he said.
Ross, however, believes that global cross-listing of ETFs is not in all cases going to be a slam dunk. An example he gives is Asia. Even though SSgA has had limited experience with cross-listings into Asia so far, Ross says that the ETF provider has learned some valuable early lessons about the realities of cross-listings among different exchanges.
Right now, the SPDR Gold Trust (NYSE: GLD) is cross-listed on exchanges in Singapore, Hong Kong and Tokyo. Also, the SPDR Trust (NYSE: SPY) has been cross-listed in Singapore.
Ross says that GLD, which was listed in Hong Kong on July 31, has shown activity in all three markets, while SPY has barely been traded in Singapore.
The reason for that, according to SSgA, probably comes down to a key issue facing all U.S.-based ETFs cross-listing on foreign exchanges—the trading hours of underlying securities.
The U.S. equities market's trading times are 12 hours off those of most Asian markets. Therefore, SPY securities are not being traded during the Asian day, while the gold bullion that serves as the foundation of GLD is one of the few investments actually traded 24 hours a day.
|